The dog days of covering Joe Arpaio
Friday, May 23rd, 2008 by Paul Giblin
About half the time I’ve encountered Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio in recent months, he’s growled something along the lines of, “You’re the guy who used to write those columns attacking me, aren’t you?”
Yes, in fact, I am.
Back in 2003 through 2005, before I went on the political beat for the 2006 elections, I served as a metro columnist for the Tribune. Among the topics I wrote about was a Sheriff’s Office heroin ring bust that involved Scottsdale Unified School District students, and the school board’s subsequent decision to launch a drug-sniffing dog program at the high schools.
I criticized both developments. I wrote the drug bust was over-hyped and that the drug-sniffing dog program violated students’ civil liberties.
For example, in a column that ran on May 13, 2005, I noted that the so-called heroin ring bust turned up exactly three kids who were thought to have used heroin while they were students in Scottsdale’s five high school. Most of the “investigative leads” were pretty flimsy to start with, and most of the others involved marijuana, rather than heroin anyway. I wrote…
That’s not exactly an epidemic considering Scottsdale’s five high schools have a total of 8,300 students. To be precise, Arpaio’s high-profile investigation exposed 0.04 percent of the student body as heroin users – if Arpaio’s numbers are to be believed at all.
In contrast, 1.7 percent of 12th-graders nationwide are thought to have used heroin at least once in their lives, according to a 2002 study by the president’s Office of national Drug Control Policy. By those measures, Scottsdale schools are remarkably heroin free.
In the same column, I criticized the school board for its 4-1 decision to send drug-sniffing dogs to patrol the schools. I wrote that no clearing-thinking person could have come to such a decision, which indicated to me that the board members themselves must have been on something. I wrote…
Board member Molly Holzer said, “I’m excited to try this because it does send a strong message.”
Oh, it sends a strong message all right. It sends a message that we should forget about putting drug-sniffing dogs in schools. We should put them where they’re needed. We should put them in the board room.
In the same column, I wrote…
Board member Eric Meyer cast the loan dissenting vote, because he didn’t see the measure as a deterrent. He grasped the idea that drug users can stash their dope in their cars rather than in their school lockers, making dog patrols useless.
Now here’s the back story. Every time I wrote one of those columns, one of Arpaio’s people called the Tribune’s top editors the first thing in the mornings to complain that I was attacking the sheriff. It got to the point that Tribune managing editor Chris Coppola asked me, as a curtsey, to e-mail him a copy of all Arpaio-related columns the day before they ran, so that he would have a chance to read them before his phone started ringing.
Now, flash forward to my recent encounters with Arpaio. As I mentioned, when we’ve spoken either by phone or in person, he’s frequently brought up those columns, but not in an angry way.
In fact, just the opposite. It’s been more like he was reminiscing the good ol’ days. Clearly, the topic had been on his mind lately. I couldn’t figure why, but didn’t give it much thought, either.
Then earlier this week, an advance copy of his new book arrived in my in-box. The book, which was co-written by Scottsdale resident Len Sherman, is titled, “Joe’s Law: America’s Toughest Sheriff Takes on Illegal Immigration, Drugs, and Everything Else That Threatens America.”
Imagine my surprise when I got to Page 77 and came across a passage in which Arpaio discussed the school board’s decision to send in the dogs.
That didn’t make any sense to me. Dogs might be fine for sniffing out lockers, but how long would it take any students holding narcotics to figure out how to get around the dogs, to keep them out of their lockers and, for example, store them (in) their cars in the parking lot? In a fairly unusual event, the media expressed disdain that mirrored my own about the school board’s idea. The plan was destined to fall apart of its own ill-conceived weight.
Wow. Who knew?




Imagine the surprise when Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio appeared on